basykes/Flickr
Should you buy used shoes? My answer used to be a resounding “NO,” but now I answer “maybe.”
When I was little, I was pigeon toed. I had to wear sturdy shoes to correct my stance at a time when sturdy shoes were very OUT. As socially debilitating as the experience was, I learned a thing or two about how shoes affect your feet and how your feet affect the rest of your body.
When you wear someone’s shoes, you are inheriting their improper body alignment and foot problems.
This is because when you are wearing shoes, the weight of your body wears down the heels and bends the fabric to match your pressures. Someone with properly aligned hips and strong ankles would wear out the heels of their shoes in the middle, not to one side or the other.
It used to be that people had one or two pairs of shoes. However, in this day and age of Imelda Marcos shoe shoppers, you can easily find shoes at a yard sale or thrift shop that have never been worn or only worn once or twice. But should you buy them?
Here is how you check if too many miles have been put on the second hand shoes you are considering buying:
- Check the heels for wear. If you see any wear, the shoes have been worn too much to buy.
- Check for wear and tear inside the shoes. Has the size been worn off? Are there indentations in the insoles? Sometimes you won’t see the wear on the heels, but it will show up inside the shoe.
- Is the shoe sitting straight? Are the sides up and down or are they at an angle? Any sag or bulge or deviation from the original shape is a sign that you do not want to inherit the back problems of the previous owner.
If you find a pair of shoes that you just HAVE to have because they perfectly match your new pink taffeta ball gown that you plan to wear to Comic Con, but they have worn heels; don’t despair. Do what your ancestors did. Buy them and take them to a cobbler and have new heels put on them.
Don’t turn your nose up at used shoes. Just make sure to inspect them for wear before purchasing. I got a pair of brand new $200 handmade Brazilian leather shoes for my husband at a Really Free Swap. Score!
Welcome to Bargain Babe! I’m Mara, and I’m so glad you’re here. I am an obsessive bargain hunter and penny pincher, and I am determined to live a full life without EVER paying full price. 
No – used shoes are too skeavy for me. It just seems wrong…
I have foot issues and fitting issues so I wouldn’t buy used shoes.
If you do get used shoes, make sure that you spray them so that you don’t pick up something nasty like a fungus.
What do you spray it with?
Nawwww…I buy used shoes! I recently bought a beautiful pair of PRADA ankle boots for 45.00. My DD told me that they are hundreds new! Perfect condition….SCORE!!!
…and I have bought many others at resale boutiques! No fungus for me….!
Buying someone else’s shoes is just gross! I always wonder if anyone really buys these when I see them at yard sales………yuck!
I’m on the fence with this one. I went to a yard sale once and bought a pair of Earth Shoe sandals new in the box, still had tissue paper wrapped in the shoes, and were my size. They had obviously never been worn, and I picked them up for $5. I love these shoes, and have worn them into the ground over the past few years. I also have a dear friend give me a pair of boots that she wore two of three times. They were my size but too big for her. I think I just got lucky, though. I’d be a little cautious with this one, Babe.
it must be very comfortbal
I’ve never bought shoes used. but I have a $30 limit on what im willing to spend for new shoes. I have picky feet, not sure I can skimp here.
@FinancialBondage I don’t think I could live with a $30 limit on shoes. Wow! You must have amazing self-control.